By Julia Felmanas, Member of PT (Partido dos Trabalhadores / Brazilian Workers’ Party) London Nucleus.
The world is going through one of the most difficult periods in decades, when the USA’s hegemony is being threatened. Whether this will come to pass, only the future will tell. However, President Trump is well aware of his country’s loss of power and is attacking like a wounded animal.
The return to a neo-Monroe Doctrine or Donroe Doctrine, in which Trump’s administration sees the whole of the Western Hemisphere as the USA’s backyard, serves a number of purposes, both ideologically and nationalistically.
First, it is a show of strength and a way of amassing as much territory to re-establish its power. Second, Latin America is a source of extremely valuable resources for the economies of the 21st century. Third, by co-opting Latin American nations, the USA has less competition in terms of its products and services, as part of the deals with friendly countries it pushes beneficial conditions for itself, sometimes to the detriment of the that country. Fourth, the USA can yield its power to push American based technology, AI and financial platforms, maintaining the dollar as the main world currency by ensuring non-regulation, deregulation or insisting on the use of American services. Finally, the USA hopes to win back lost ground from China which has invested heavily in the region.
One could say that a few personal reasons also come into play such as Trump’s arrogance and megalomania or the US State Department’s Secretary, Marco Rubio’s, unresolved psychological issues with his Latin American identity.
Current situation
Most of Latin America has already turned right. Most notably, Argentina, Chile and Colombia. But we cannot rule out blatant interference in the Honduras election. It is also important to mention Keiko Fujimori’s win in Peru. Furthermore, the kidnapping of Maduro in Venezuela in an open attack to its sovereignty and wealth, whilst Cuba remains under permanent sanctions and is threatened with military interference.
However, two countries stand in the way of the USA in fulfilling it wish to impose the so-called Donroe Doctrine: Mexico and Brazil.
The Brazilian elections provide the perfect opportunity for the USA to co-opt Brazil without spilling blood. Indeed, with the help of Brazilians themselves. A win for Bolsonaro’s son, Flávio, would mean a huge victory for Trump and the far right, with immense implications not only in Latin America, but the world. Whilst Lula’s victory is an opportunity for resistance and fighting back. Brazil would continue to be a bastion in the struggle for multilateralism, human rights, peace and the environment.
Why is Brazil so important?
First of all, simply because of what Brazil is: the fifth largest country in geographical terms, 7th most populous in the world and 8th in term of GDP, depending how you count it. It has large mineral reserves: critical minerals, rare earths, iron ore, oil and others. It is an agricultural powerhouse on which the USA both depends on (coffee, orange juice, meat, wood, etc.) and competes with (meat, cotton, soya, wood, etc).
It has the largest freshwater reserves in the world, the largest biodiversity, the cleanest electricity mix and a huge potential for clean, renewable energy. It has complex, well-developed systems of technology, finances and markets and the sheer size of its population means that no internationally-minded company can ignore it.
The USA used to be Brazil’s main market. No longer. China is now its principal trading partner, and Brazil has been diversifying its trade partnerships, so that it is less reliant on the USA in comparison to a few decades ago.
Then there is Lula’s and Brazil’s long-standing international position on geopolitical matters, which does not please current American foreign policy. Brazil is a strong voice for multilateralism, south-south relations and peace. It is also a founding member of BRICS which have increased in size and now counts with 11 full members and 10 partner countries. BRICS is an alternative system to US hegemony, with a real potential for debanking the dollar from being the main world currency.
Furthermore, Brazil does not align with the USA and Europe in relation to the main current global conflicts: It is clear with regard to its position on the genocidal attacks of Israel in Palestinian territory. It has proclaimed the need to protect both Cuba’s and Venezuela’s sovereignty. It diverges on solutions regarding the Russia-Ukraine conflict, the war with Iran. It has a different view on China and proclaims the need to respect the sovereignty of nations, most specifically in Latin-America and the Caribbean.
Democracy under threat internally and externally
Elections take place on 4th October and there is already evidence of American interference. At the end of August, the Brazilian intelligence services sent a report to the Brazilian government that was later leaked, where it pointed to the escalation of economic, political and diplomatic pressure from the USA and that this had reached critical levels. It highlighted already well-known cases of pressure and interference such as the increase in tariffs – of up to 50% in some cases – on Brazilian goods. Sanctions on individuals and companies, including members of the Supreme Court and government officials. Diplomatic restrictions, such as revoking the visa of Brazil’s Ambassador in Washington.
Furthermore, as well as pressuring Brazil to get rid of its free-to-use payment platform PIX, it has classified organised criminal gangs such as Brazilian PCC and PV as terrorist organisations, the implications of which are that the Americans can militarily invade Brazil, if they so wish, under the pretext that it would be fighting terrorist organisations. The intelligence agency report particularly highlights Rubio’s potential for interference in the elections in favour of the Bolsonaros.
Unfortunately, the USA is not alone in attacking Brazilian democracy. The country’s mainstream media’s dislike for Lula is notorious, reflecting the national elite’s vicious anti Workers’ Party (PT) stance. To cap it all, the Superior Electoral Courts, with legal oversight of elections, are in the hands of a Justice chosen by Bolsonaro, Nunes Marques. Whilst a second Justice, Mendonça, also put in place by Bolsonaro, was in charge of the Master Bank fraud cases which directly implicate Flávio Bolsonaro, some right-wing congressmen and Supreme Justices themselves. These investigations have been repressed so far, impeding the Brazilian public of access to crucial information on which to base their voting decisions. There are increasing signs that Electoral Court decisions are not as impartial as they should be.
However, nothing beats the Bolsonaro’s family disdain for their own country. Flavio Bolsonaro’s brother, Eduardo, left Brazil and his position as Federal Deputy for the USA so as to lobby the American government. As well as facilitating a number of meetings with Trump and other members of the US government for his brother, Eduardo has advocated for tariffs against Brazil, cast doubt on Brazil’s electronic ballot system, asked for further sanctions for (non-allied) Supreme Justices and praised the USA’s governments’ reclassification of organised crime. But perhaps most disturbing, is that Flavio Bolsonaro declared to Rubio that should he win, his transition team would be at the service of the USA government.
In addition, there is social media. As well as permitting disinformation, misinformation and spreading of fake news, a number of accounts, including Lula’s, have been temporarily blocked, most notably by Meta (Facebook and Instagram), a few days before the elections. A win for Bolsonaro is clearly in their interest. Besides ideological affinity, Lula and the Brazilian establishment have shown willingness to regulate AI and tech in general, as well as implementing initiatives to produce national platforms and content.
Finally, there are signs that the Rockbridge network, a far-right organisation co-founded by J.D. Vance, has been meddling in the elections. Its subsidiary, Rockbridge Brazil, is apparently supporting Flávio Bolsonaro’s campaign. According to some alternative media outlets, this includes flooding mainstream media with cash to repress negative information about Flávio Bolsonaro. The situation is so worrisome that 31 American congressmen wrote to Rubio expressing their concern.
Lula used his speech at the UN to warn about what could come to pass during the election. When Lula won in 2022, Biden was in power. The American former president was well aware that a Bolsonaro win would have bolstered Trump and proceeded to immediately recognise the fairness of Brazil’s election.
Now, we already see signs that the American administration may not recognise the elections if Lula wins. A win for Bolsonaro’s son would not only spell disaster for Brazil and Latin America, but for the rest of the world.
In Brazil, those most likely to suffer from a Flávio Bolsonaro win are the most vulnerable: the poor, the black and indigenous populations, women, lgbt+ communities and minorities in general. But perhaps what is most important is something I have not mentioned yet: this summer we have seen the consequences of reaching environmental limits. Brazil holds the largest pristine tropical forest areas in the world, Its preservation is essential for humanity’s survival. The far right in power in Brazil would mean that any hope the world has of attempting to remain within liveable limits is lost forever.